A legal brief has been filed by the plaintiffs in a case brought by a group of local taxpayers who believe state lawmakers have no right to give their tax dollars to private businesses.
James Ostrowski, the Buffalo attorney who represents 46 taxpayers interested in putting an end to state subsidies for corporations, presented the plaintiffs’ written argument as to why their case should prevail Sept. 15 in New York state Supreme Court in Albany.
“In light of all the financial meltdown it becomes increasingly harder to justify giving our money away to wealthy corporations,” Ostrowski said.
The suit, funded with taxpayer donations and driven by Lockport businessman Lee Bordeleau, asks the court for an injunction barring the state from giving public funds to private corporations. It also asks for the return of state funds transferred to private entities under this year’s budget and for a declaration that says it is illegal for the state to transfer money to private corporations unless the transaction falls under exceptions specifically outlined under Article VII of the state Constitution. The plaintiffs argue state law requires funds paid out of the state treasury be limited to those authorized by “appropriations of law” that “distinctly specify the sum appropriated and the object or purpose to which it is to be applied.” The plaintiffs argue that the state budget often includes provisions for cash grants without defining how exactly appropriated dollars will be spent.
“Such provisions not only violate the Constitution but also promote secrecy, concentrate enormous financial power into the hands of a few and reduce public accountability for appropriations such as cash grants for wealthy corporations,” the plaintiffs claim states.
The lawsuit, which required four months of legal research, traces New York state government’s financial dealings back to the 1840s when the plaintiffs say large loans and grants provided to businesses in the guise of economic development failed, leaving state taxpayers to deal with the higher taxes needed to pay off the loan guarantees. The plaintiffs note that the state’s Constitution was amended in 1846 to ban loans to private firms, with voters approving the amendment, 221,528 to 92,436. A year later, the plaintiffs say, the provision was expanded to include a ban on giving state money to private firms. And while the provision has been modified over the years, the plaintiffs claim that none of the subsequent exceptions give the state permission to give away public money in the name of “economic development.”
“We can find no reported appellate case that squarely holds that such cash grants pass constitutional muster,” the plaintiffs maintain.
Ostrowski said he expects the state to file its response in about two weeks.
In the past, representatives from the state’s Empire State Development Corp. have insisted that its financial dealings with companies, including grant-funded projects, are in compliance with the state’s constitution and all applicable laws.
Local News
LAWSUIT: Written argument filed in effort to end state subsidies for corporations.
- Local News
-
-
Town cop faces disciplinary action
Assessor chosen; meeting scheduled over Amigone crematory.
-
New York ties safety record
Four fatalities, 26 injured.
-
Senate passes bus legislation
Bills intended to make riding bus safer for students, enhance communication.
-
Lasting legacy
Parks and Recreation chief Foels, longest-tenured city employee, even busier in retirement.
-
NT coach fired for relationship
Superintendent says criminal charges will not be filed.
-
No new vet for Niagara SPCA
Lawyers and board members will meet with state attorney general’s representative later today.
-
A red carpet affair
On Feb. 12, the red carpet will be rolled out, the champagne will flow, the flashbulbs will be popping and, yes, the paparazzi will be swarming.
-
Two arrested after traffic stop
Two women were arrested following a traffic stop and subsequent dispute with City of Tonawanda police early Saturday.
-
DWI suspect hit signs on way to KFC
A Niagara Falls man was arrested for DWI and other traffic charges Friday night after striking two traffic signs on the Twin Cities Memorial Highway on his way to pick up some fried chicken.
-
School Wide Web
Starpoint eighth graders lead Friday special event.
- More Local News Headlines
-
Town cop faces disciplinary action
Stranded Fishermen Rescued From Bay of Green Bay
Analyst: Outside Troops Won't Intervene in Syria
Murder Trial for Ex-U.Va. Lacrosse Player Begins
NY Giants Touch Down Victorious
Police: Father Planned Deadly Fire for Some Time
US, UK Pressure on Syria; More Homs Violence
Raw Video: Mass Killer Wants Medal, Freedom
Few Answers in Death of Sons of Missing Utah Mom
Court Strips Contador of Tour De France Title
Runaway Goat Leads Police on Wild Chase
And the Winner for Best Super Bowl Ad Is...
Raw Video: Deadly Helicopter Crash in Australia
Raw Video: Smoke, Purported Gunfire in Syria
Romney Latest Poll to Join Let-me-explain Club
Blast Kills Husband of Missing Utah Mom, 2 Boys
Obama: US, Israel Will Work Against Iran Nukes
NJ Museum Finds 19th Century Recording
Snow Causes Disruptions in Much of Europe
Clinton: Vetoed U.N. Syria Resolution 'travesty'
Romney Picks Up Decisive Win in Nevada Caucuses
